Martin Below

Downvoting

  • about 3 months ago
  • 138
  • 15
updatewebsite

Downvoting

You can now help us fighting spam and unwanted content by downvoting comments and board topics.

When should I vote down?

Downvote posts that are spammy, misplaced or sloppy and do not add anything substantial to the discussion.

How do I vote down?

Click the down arrow to the right of each comment / topic. You can undo your votes by clicking the button again.

What happens when I vote down?

Comments and topics that have been downvoted multiple times are collapsed / greyed out.

Downvoting is not something we want you to take lightly! Use it wisely in the spirit to improve the platform.

Create an account or Login to write a comment.

  • User Avatar

    Sonat

    about 6 months ago

    Downvoting is silly, it is up to the account owner to oversee the comments on his page and report conduct he doesn't like. That's how it should be. If you don't like something on someone else's track, too bad. It's their job to filter the comments, not some random account downvoting things on other people's account pages or tracks. Also by the guide above, that means I should downvote people who don't write well. That's just detrimental to the AT community, which in my estimate is already growing strangely snobbish over really unimportant things.

    For the record, we should all be grateful that this FREE DAW is even available to us. Let's just keep the community ethically responsible. Don't downvote and hide comments you don't like. Instead, tell them why they're wrong or, if spam, ignore it. Accounts have the ability to delete spam from their walls or tracks and report spam if they see fit. Self policing this issue by mob rule of voting is not going to make this a happier community. It's going to be abused and also tick off a lot of people whose comments will be shot down and unavailable.

    Many thanks to the AT creator(s) for even allowing this site to be free. Y'all's the real MVPs.

    • User Avatar

      sndbrgn

      about 6 months ago

      Have a look at the Sample Upload Temporarily Disabled thread. In my opinion the Downvote was used in a senseful way. I haven't seen any abuse over the time this function has existed. At least not in the quantity predicted by some doomsayers

    1 more
  • User Avatar

    PsychicNinjaSilverMoon

    about 7 months ago

    When the post about downvoting has been downvoted about 700 times XD

    • User Avatar

      Sonat

      about 6 months ago

      Downvoting is dumb. If something breaks guidelines then it should just be removed, it shouldn't be up to couple of people who just downvote opinions they don't like.

  • User Avatar

    naswalt

    about 8 months ago

    oops. "Downvoting is not something we want you to take lightly! Use it wisely in the spirit to improve the platform."

    I'll stop.

  • User Avatar

    Martin Below

    about 8 months ago

    Update: Downvotes no longer cancel out Upvotes

    • User Avatar

      André Michelle

      about 8 months ago

      They won't. That is the point.

    • User Avatar

      i17

      about 8 months ago

      I mean how would they know?

    • User Avatar

      André Michelle

      about 8 months ago

      Same way you did before. Open the context-menu (hamburger) and see if down-vote is active (blue).

    1 more
  • User Avatar

    Ty Freestyle

    about 8 months ago

    Man, downvoting sucks. It simply adds negativity to the site. You can never see who actually downvotes, so people can hide behind hating other people's comments anonymously, which I think is terrible. And if people don't like this very comment, my personal opinion, which affects no one in any way shape or form, enough anonymous clicks of the mouse can hide my comment. On many track, there are downvoted comments that are not "spammy, misplaced or sloppy and do not add anything substantial to the discussion", but instead, are just people being hateful to the specific artist, track, or are just being all around annoying. And I see people asking for help and tips on how to make music (not asking for people to listen, or spam), and people downvote innocent comments such as this. At least we should be able to see who downvotes. Because as of now, many comments that are in fact important are getting taken down without reason, while the perpetrators of the occurence go unknown. I also agree with this by Xom: : "if we want the downvote and upvote buttons to do what they're intended to do, i don't think, for example, that one downvote and one upvote on a comment should cancel eachother out to zero. instead there should be a 1 by the upvote button and a 1 by the downvote button so that the information the numbers show can be more telling of how many people downvoted, even if the majority happened to upvote instead, or visa versa" .

    My overall verdict: right now, downvoting is not beneficial at all, given how it occurs. Could it ever be beneficial? Maybe. But it needs fixing again. I should emphasize - this is meant to be my personal opinion, it is not supposed to offend anyone including the creators of audiotool. My criticism is harsh, but it needs to be said. :) - Ty Freestyle

    • User Avatar

      André Michelle

      about 8 months ago

      We are constantly adjusting features to make them better. Sometimes we overshoot and we are happy for any reasonable feedback. Upvotes and Downvotes no longer cancel each other out. Let's see if this already resolves things to the better.

    • User Avatar

      Ty Freestyle

      about 8 months ago

      @André Michelle Thank you for acknowledging me. I agree with all of that. To be fair, I have only been on here for 1 year (about) so then downvotes wouldn't be available to me. I think its less about experience on the site necessarily, and more about how the process is. Thank you though! Glad to see my paragraph wasn't in vain... :)

    • User Avatar

      i17

      about 8 months ago

      ... 2 years is a little too much.

    4 more
  • User Avatar

    fiireheart!

    about 8 months ago

    I like it I hate the hateful comments and supposedly "advice". Thanks AT!

    • User Avatar

      yonko.

      about 8 months ago

      theres a difference between actually constructive criticism, and obvious hate

      whether or not u feel like learning to discern that is ur own problem

    • User Avatar

      yonko.

      about 8 months ago

      u know, most of the time 'supposedly advice' is usually actual advice that u just refuse to take cause u and people like u are too stuck on cloud nine to accept it

  • User Avatar

    moonriver

    about 8 months ago

    "Downvoting is not something we want you to take lightly! Use it wisely in the spirit to improve the platform."

    I dont think this is TOO subjective, but I also dont think it's wrong to predict that given enough time, the value of a downvote will decrease in a sort of treadmill effect. The "bad" threshold for a downvote will slide lower in time.

    That being said, I dont find reddit or google to suffer too much from this effect. If my comment gets downvoted because people dont like or agree with it, I move on. I think some of us are getting a bit too hung up on being able to downvote things that they just don't agree with or don't like it. If that happens, so be it.

  • User Avatar

    NASSIV

    about 8 months ago

    if we want the downvote and upvote buttons to do what they're intended to do, i don't think, for example, that one downvote and one upvote on a comment should cancel eachother out to zero. instead there should be a 1 by the upvote button and a 1 by the downvote button so that the information the numbers show can be more telling of how many people downvoted, even if the majority happened to upvote instead, or visa versa

    • User Avatar

      NASSIV

      about 8 months ago

      i agree with my 2-weeks-ago self

    • User Avatar

      NASSIV

      about 8 months ago

      of course, this problem would already be solved if everyone on the internet could respect eachothers' differences, but of course that's never gonna happen

    • User Avatar

      NASSIV

      about 8 months ago

      but now that i think of it, it could work the other way, cuz being able to see nicknames of the people that upvoted a comment that the majority may not like could also make the majority end up "witchhunting" the minority

    4 more
  • User Avatar

    Gray Out

    about 8 months ago

    I'm sure all of this has been said but: Reporting the comment should be a separate function from down-voting imo, I don't really like the idea of effective censorship which could possibly arise from this feature when certain people/communities/ideas come into contact. Reporting should be reserved for situations of great gravity, while down-voting could be a bit more lighthearted in nature. I don't mind keeping everything prim and proper but AT's community could be dulled by this I think. Also could breed a sense of hostility among the sites less mature users (you down-voted my comment? i'll just down-vote yours then), which would kind of defeat the point of the down-vote system. Just talking here, not sure how much of this would actually happen.

    5 more
  • User Avatar

    ApoC (4OurLives)

    about 9 months ago
    • User Avatar

      NASSIV

      about 8 months ago

      vvv wut

    2 more
00:00
06:03